THE NASIK PROJECT | Conversation on India’s Small Cities

Summarising the "Conversation on India's Small Cities", by The Nasik Project, a symposium delving into the question of what constitutes a second-tier or small city beyond mere quantitative metrics.

SHARE THIS

Small Cities play a significant role in India’s decentralised network of urban centers yet the discussions around them are few and far. The two-day symposium by The Nasik Project on India’s small cities began with understanding what constitutes a small city.

Symposium Day 1:

Shreyank Khemalapure presented various scales of small cities and what they entail, touching upon examples to elaborate the character of these cities. It was followed by an engaging conversation with Rajesh Advani.

In the second session, Pushkar Sohoni and Sonal Mithal discussed the histories of small cities. Pushkar traced the transformation of cities such as Solapur to project their changing characteristics over a timeline by uncovering factors contributing to the rise and decline of small cities. Sonal highlighted the history of Surat, a city on the cusp of transformation and growth. She positioned the history of Surat Castle in the context of the city’s past and detailed her work on its conservation.

Catherine and Purva’s observations and questions brought to light further nuances. Sonal’s perspective on contemporizing history to make it relevant today advocated to bridge the gap between the past and the present. Pushkar highlighted the need for a systems approach to our cities, focused on integrating interdisciplinary perspectives.

The last presentation of the day was on practicing in small cities, delivered by Bobby Desai of HCP Design, Planning and Management. He explained the detailed process and execution of planning the Kashi Vishwanath Dham Corridor in Varanasi. As he concluded his presentation, he asked if the project was a big project in a small city or a small project in a big city, before zooming out a satellite image of the city highlighting the scale of the project.

In the moderation session, Nitin Patel and Archis Kulkarni extended the question to the scale of impact of the project and how such projects can be seen as an opportunity to define or rather redefine the way we think about architecture of sacred and religious spaces. 

Day 1 of the symposium. © The Nasik Project
Day 1 of the symposium. © The Nasik Project

Symposium Day 2:

The second day of the symposium began with two interesting presentations by Percy Pithawala and Praveen Bavadekar, exploring the theme of the city as an entity.

Percy discussed his practice based in Vadodara and the architecture competitions he and his students had participated in. He also touched upon architectural education in small cities, by citing his engagement as an academic in Vadodara.

Praveen unpacked the history of Belgaum and situated his practice alongside his personal identity. By showing projects that had contributed to the city of Belgaum, he explored the relation of architecture and the city.

Rahul Dabir and Pooja Khairnar extended the conversation with their questions.

Ruturaj Parekh presented the second session on Practicing in small cities. He began with talking about his personal journey and eventually shared his projects in Bihar and Goa. Ajay Sonar and Amol Suryavanshi moderated the talk.

The keynote speaker was Dr. Praveen Gedam, the divisional commissioner of Nasik. He emphasised the need for citizen participation in the growth of Nasik. His session was moderated by Bakir Zafar and Nitin Kute.

The session was followed by many questions from the audience. By answering the questions, Dr. Gedam spoke about the upcoming 2027 Kumbh Mela in the city and the proposed development of the city’s periphery.

The symposium attempted to generate focussed discussions on select small cities highlighting the research and practices that are meaningfully contributing towards such smaller yet significant urban centres. The discussions have ushered a heightened interest in the city and have initiated a much-needed discussion on our small cities.

Note: The recordings of all the sessions are available on YouTube

Day 2 of the symposium. © The Nasik Project
Day 2 of the symposium. © The Nasik Project

Credits:

Curated by: Yakin Kinger, Swapnil Joshi, and Krushna Rathi.
Advisory panel: Sanjay Patil, Bakir Zafar, Nitin Patel, Ajay Sonar, and Chandrakant Dhamne.
Supported by: IIA Nashik Centre.
Media partner: ArchitectureLive!
Collaborators: INTACH Nashik Chapter, CREDAI Nashik Metro, and IIID Nashik Regional Chapter.
Feature Image: Patterns of Mylapore. © Vinoth Chandar

Like what we publish?

AUTHOR

The Nasik Project
The Nasik Project
Profile and Contributions

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Recent Posts

A Modernist’s Doubt: Symbolism and the Late Career Turn

Why did acclaimed modernist architects suddenly introduce historical symbolism like arches, decorative elements, and other cultural references into their work after decades of disciplined restraint? Sudipto Ghosh interrogates this 1980s-90s symbolic turn as a rupture in architecture, questioning whether this represents an authentic reconnection with content and memory, or is it a mere superficial gesture towards absent meanings. Drawing from Heidegger’s analysis of the Greek temple, he distinguishes two modes of architectural representation, ultimately judging that this turn was a nascent rebellion against modernism that may have failed to achieve genuine integration of context, material, and memory.

Read More »
Ode to Pune - A Vision. © Narendra Dengle - 1

The City That Could Be: An Ode to Pune

Narendra Dengle, through his poem written in January 2006, presents a deep utopic vision for Pune—what the city could be as an ecologically sustainable, equitable city that balances nature with development. He sets ambitious benchmarks for prioritizing public transport over cars, preserving heritage, addressing slum rehabilitation humanely, and empowering local communities

Read More »
(left) Turtle Poem 1999 & Calligraphy 2006, by H. Masud Taj. © H. Masud Taj. (right) Photograph of Hassan Fathy 1976, © Martin Lyons

“Hassan Fathy’s head was in the heavens, heart in the right place, and feet planted firmly on earth.”—H. Masud Taj on his Turtle poem & Hassan Fathy

H. Masud Taj elucidates how, as a young architecture student, he dropped out of his institution to travel and learn from monuments, discovering in Gaudí’s Sagrada Familia a turtle column that catalyzed an inquiry, hearing Hassan Fathy’s explication of the turtle in Cairo, ultimately crystallizing in Taj’s poetic meditation on dwelling.

Read More »
Education Authority Bill - Viksit Bharat Shiksha Adhishthan Bill - Architecture Education, A. Srivathsan

Education Authority Bill: Its Implications for Architecture Education

A. Srivathsan in his preliminary overview of the new Viksit Bharat Shiksha Adhishthan Bill, notes that the bill could transform architectural education. The VBSA Bill proposes restructuring India’s higher education regulation, by dissolving UGC and related authorities, creating three new councils for regulation, accreditation, and standards.

Read More »
Open Hand Monument, Chandigarh. Via Chandigarh Tourism

Revisiting Chandigarh: A Vitalised Metaphoric Urban Forest

Suneet Paul reflects on Chandigarh’s modernist planning, lush green spaces, and iconic architecture, highlighting architects like Le Corbusier’s and S.D. Sharma’s contributions, high quality of life for residents, and the city’s enduring appeal despite emerging urban challenges.

Read More »

Featured Publications

New Release

We Are Hiring

Stories that provoke enquiry into built environment

www.architecture.live

Subscribe & Join a Community of Lakhs of Readers