IIM Ahmedabad

Belief and Building | Himanshu Burte

IIM Ahmedabad
I was recently at IIM Ahmedabad walking around Louis Kahn’s masterpiece. I have always enjoyed being there, but this time during my third or fourth visit, strangely, I resonated with Kahn’s impeccable rhythms like never before. It was also the first time that I really saw the poor health of the brickwork he was so deeply invested in.
ArchitectureLive Himanshu burte Louis Kahn
Kahn is said to have been inspired by Roman ruins. But he would have been dismayed at the cracks, the patchwork of repair and replacement that many walls at IIM observed, less than five decades after they were built. The brickwork has simply not worn well. The problem for repairers is simple and almost insurmountable. These are load-bearing walls, multiple storeys tall. When parts of those walls start cracking or splitting, what do you do? You cannot replace parts of the wall on an upper floor without taking down the part below it. The exercise soon starts looking like a reconstruction job.
Belief and Building | Himanshu Burte 2
A senior architect informally told me that one reason for the bad state of the walls was that Kahn had the bricks sandpapered to heighten their already rough texture. Another problem appears to be the steel reinforcement in the piers. The steel has corroded and expanded pushing the brickwork out. Long, heartbreaking cracks run up and down the brickwork as a result.
There is perhaps a lesson in all this. As I read- it is about the relationship between beliefs, about how buildings ought to be and how they actually are. I don’t know any details about both the things I heard about the brickwork- that it was roughened and, therefore, unwittingly made more porous, or the fact that steel reinforcement was placed in the brickwork directly. I, thus, don’t know for certain whether they are true or if yes, in what way they are. However, I later thought it was interesting that both are immediately believable for someone like me, who has, for long, been a part of architectural culture.
Both problems appear to be rooted in a simple fallacy: letting a vision for architecture or a theoretical position about it override the demands of construction and weatherproofing. The rough look might have heightened the apparent timelessness of the building which was a central quality of the environment that Kahn sought to create. But it might well have compromised the durability of the structure.
The steel reinforcement in the brick is a slightly deeper issue. I don’t know whether Kahn asked for the steel to be put into the brickwork. That is unlikely, though it might well be that the structural designers wanted it in and Kahn had to agree. I wondered why he simply did not build little columns of RCC into the core of the brickwork where required. The concrete could simply have functioned as a ‘cover’ for the steel against weathering and saved much of the bother. As soon as I thought of it, I realized that would never wash with Kahn’s underlying search for authenticity in his fascination with origins. A brick wall with steel reinforcement compromises the purity of the brick’s reputation for strength. An RCC column (even one where the concrete bears no compressive load) would simply destroy that reputation. So, if Kahn had actually considered the RCC option, he might well have had a good reason within his philosophy to reject it. This means, if you don’t mind continuing with the if-then game a little longer, his desire for an effect of timelessness as well as for ‘authenticity’ (brickwork actually being made to do all the work it is seen to do with arches and buttresses) actually led to the very opposite outcome physically. The architecture is experienced as timeless but its substance has begun succumbing too quickly to the weathering effects played out in time. This suggests that beliefs about architecture might sometimes go against the good sense related to building.

Author – Himanshu Burte, is an architect and an Assistant Professor at the School of Habitat Studies, at Tata Institute of Social Sciences, Mumbai. A graduate of Sir JJ College of Architecture, Mumbai (B. Arch. 1990), Himanshu has been actively involved in architectural practice, research, writing and teaching. He has written extensively on architecture, art and urbanism in the popular and professional press, and has been invited to speak at many national and international conferences in India and abroad. His first book, ‘Space for Engagement: The Indian Artplace and a Habitational Approach to Architecture’ was published in 2008 by Seagull Books, Kolkata _ Read more about him here

One Response

  1. i wonder if a large part of the structural damage was caused by the major earthquake in 2001?

    many rcc framed exposed brick buildings (for example NID)had to be structurally rehabilitated post the earthquake.
    saleem bhatri

Share your comments

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


The 100, Calicut, by Nestcraft Architecture

In this rural escape, The 100, Calicut, by Nestccraft Architecture, ensures a firm marriage between functionality and aesthetics and the planning suggests four bedrooms with attached toilets in a plinth area of 21OO square feet. The home and wabi-sabi landscape within this boundary facilitate meaningful life to 1OO souls.

Read More »

Pune – An Ever-Evolving Jewel

The essay traces the transformation of Pune from a quaint town to the vibrant city it is today. Mostly it is about the city’s aspects, which make it different and unique. The narrative reminisces about the city’s cultural richness and festive glory. It also points out a bit about the challenges posed by urbanization. But despite everything, Pune successfully retains its cultural essence, making it a city that preserves its glorious heritage while transforming.
This essay by Arpita Khamitkar is amongst the shortlisted essays.

Read More »

Reflection of Urban Inclusivity And Reality

The essay reflects on the author’s childhood memories centred around the Kohinoor Textile Mill. The mill, part of Mumbai’s Girangaon, played a significant role in the city’s industrial growth until the early 1980s. The essay fondly recalls the mill’s impact on the community, its cultural richness, and personal experiences. The author expresses concern about the loss of community identity and the impact of privatization, highlighting the need for sustainable urban development that preserves the city’s history. This essay by Pornima Buddhivant is amongst the shortlisted essays.

Read More »
The case of Phalke Smarak - Nashik

The case of Phalke Smarak

The essay titled, ‘The case of Phalke Smarak : Nashik’s untapped potential with existing urban public space’ – discusses how a promising urban scale public space project for Nashik city in the late 90s has slowly turned desolate, despite all the possibilities and potential the architectural design, site and overall context offers. It further tries to highlight the gap between the public and failed public spaces based on this case, and points towards public engagement for successful urban design, renewal and development. This essay by Asmita Raghuvanshy is amongst the shortlisted essays.

Read More »
The Good, the Bad and the Aesthetic - Bhopal

The Good, the Bad and the Aesthetic

This essay delves into how municipal corporations envision creating Western cities (instead of responding to the Indian context) and end up creating cities that only appear to work, instead of actually being more socially inclusive, dynamic and publicly active. The Smart Cities Mission then caters only to the rich and this becomes evident in not just the visuals they use, but also the manner in which they describe their vision of a World Class Infrastructure. This essay by Avani Mittal is amongst the shortlisted essays.

Read More »


ArchitectureLive! is hiring for various roles, starting from senior editors, content writers, research associates, graphic designer and more..