Architecture Disconnected

the institutions have failed the profession.. – Nalini Thakur

Architecture Disconnected

We continue our discussion on Architecture – Disconnected?’, inviting the opinions of Prof. Nalini Thakur from School of Planning and Architecture, Delhi – and she approaches the issue from an institutional angle, talking about how the academic setup can – and must – play a role in bridging this gap.

Architectural profession in India is lost and in crisis. I would not credit this distancing to a conscious decision – instead, it has been drifting with no substance or direction. We lack the ability to keep pace with rapid change; we have no leadership or vision, to inspire or guide us. Most of all, the institutions have failed the profession.

I do think it is a post-colonial impact on all of us. The information we absorb in architecture schools is totally irrelevant to our culture, only suited to our colonized status in the past – leading to a state of confusion.  This has resulted in our inability to build a relevant cultural knowledge base rooted in our indigenous context. Such a base is necessary for us to imbibe learning that we can integrate with our design problems.

For recovering from this crisis and closing the gap, the starting point is education.  The leading institutions must take on the responsibility and attempt to do the needful, and set an example. Also, individual architects should focus on carrying out quality work – they cannot take on the big problems of the profession on their shoulders.  There are specific roles and responsibilities for each person/agency.

We are talking about a new paradigm in architectural education – the post-colonial context. We as teachers can take on a part …Let us start.

3 Responses

  1. Dear Prof. Nalini Thakur , after much Time and Space delighted to read your lines on architecture context and content with culture and heritage to add value. YES, I am with you all the way. But in this jungle what prevails. Even the jungle has its defined designs. But in our built environment, imitate and paste has become the order. Students do not even peruse challenges of imagination and innovation.
    Yes, there are a few who stray the lonely path. But Institutions and schools must and can play a deeper role, awakening the senses to our lives in this subcontinent on this earth.
    Let more souls spirited like you be the path breakers.
    http://www.jaisimfountainhead.in

  2. THERE ARE TWELVE LAKES CIVIL ENGINEERS AND SEVENTY FIVE THOUSAND ARCHITECTS ARE IN INDIA. BIG BOSS YOU HAVE DESTROYED 75% OF BUILT UP AREA.DAY BY DAY TRAFFIC, ANIMAL AND HUMAN POPULATION ARE INCREASING.YOU WANT TO PROTECT THE BIRDS AND ANIMAL KINGDOM. BUT WE DON T CARE ABOUT POLLUTION.SINCE WE ARE UN EDUCATED THE RULES, RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT DONT APPLY OUR DAY TO DAY LIFE.OUR GIFTED ARCHITECTS HAVE BECOME CARTOONIST AND ACTORS.WAKE UP GO FILL THE PARLIAMENT HOUSE AND STATE ASSEMBLY HALL.IF YOU DEVELOP THE LOCAL SMART CITY, STUDENTS WILL LEARN BY THEMSELVES.LET THE BOYS AND GIRLS ENJOY THEIR TEENAGE WALK.DON T FORCE YOUR VISION. UNIVERSE IS WITH THEIR E NOTE BOOK.
    REGARDS,
    rajan.

Share your comments

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Recent

The 100, Calicut, by Nestcraft Architecture

In this rural escape, The 100, Calicut, by Nestccraft Architecture, ensures a firm marriage between functionality and aesthetics and the planning suggests four bedrooms with attached toilets in a plinth area of 21OO square feet. The home and wabi-sabi landscape within this boundary facilitate meaningful life to 1OO souls.

Read More »
Pune

Pune – An Ever-Evolving Jewel

The essay traces the transformation of Pune from a quaint town to the vibrant city it is today. Mostly it is about the city’s aspects, which make it different and unique. The narrative reminisces about the city’s cultural richness and festive glory. It also points out a bit about the challenges posed by urbanization. But despite everything, Pune successfully retains its cultural essence, making it a city that preserves its glorious heritage while transforming.
This essay by Arpita Khamitkar is amongst the shortlisted essays.

Read More »

Reflection of Urban Inclusivity And Reality

The essay reflects on the author’s childhood memories centred around the Kohinoor Textile Mill. The mill, part of Mumbai’s Girangaon, played a significant role in the city’s industrial growth until the early 1980s. The essay fondly recalls the mill’s impact on the community, its cultural richness, and personal experiences. The author expresses concern about the loss of community identity and the impact of privatization, highlighting the need for sustainable urban development that preserves the city’s history. This essay by Pornima Buddhivant is amongst the shortlisted essays.

Read More »
The case of Phalke Smarak - Nashik

The case of Phalke Smarak

The essay titled, ‘The case of Phalke Smarak : Nashik’s untapped potential with existing urban public space’ – discusses how a promising urban scale public space project for Nashik city in the late 90s has slowly turned desolate, despite all the possibilities and potential the architectural design, site and overall context offers. It further tries to highlight the gap between the public and failed public spaces based on this case, and points towards public engagement for successful urban design, renewal and development. This essay by Asmita Raghuvanshy is amongst the shortlisted essays.

Read More »
The Good, the Bad and the Aesthetic - Bhopal

The Good, the Bad and the Aesthetic

This essay delves into how municipal corporations envision creating Western cities (instead of responding to the Indian context) and end up creating cities that only appear to work, instead of actually being more socially inclusive, dynamic and publicly active. The Smart Cities Mission then caters only to the rich and this becomes evident in not just the visuals they use, but also the manner in which they describe their vision of a World Class Infrastructure. This essay by Avani Mittal is amongst the shortlisted essays.

Read More »

WE ARE HIRING /

ArchitectureLive! is hiring for various roles, starting from senior editors, content writers, research associates, graphic designer and more..

 

PARTICIPATE /